Vegetarians Live Longer, But Is It Worth It?

Umami Burger | Photo: MuyYum/Flickr/Creative Commons License

Fact: Vegetarians live longer than meat-eaters.

This, at least, is the finding from a new study by the National Institutes of Health. For the past 10 years, they've been tracking the health stats of 96,000 Seventh-Day Adventists, a religious group that practices a strict vegetarianism diet because of their "belief in the holistic nature of humankind." A side effect of that mindset, apparently, is also being a hell of a lot healthier than everyone else.

Among the findings from the study:

- Vegans, on average, are 30 pounds lighter than meat eaters.
- Vegetarians and vegans are less insulin-resistant than meat eaters.

But possibly the most important finding is the simple cold, hard fact that they live longer than the rest of us: Seventh-Day Adventist men live 9.5 years longer than Californian guys, while women live 6.1 more years. On average, that's nearly 8 more years of life than the rest of us meat-eaters.

Eight. More. Years.

Which brings us to this other shocking finding:

Second Fact: I will still continue to eat meat.

You see, whenever we're talking about about the vaguely moral question of life spans as concerned to specific diets -- be it meat vs. vegan, dairy vs. non, gluten-free or -full, or ingesting any of the things that maybe we shouldn't be allowed to eat at all -- there's an implied taunt at those who do not follow the findings from the study. "Why don't you want to be healthy, you idiot!" is often how it goes. But really, it's much more complex decision than that.

Eating healthy versus not is more of a time-share argument than anything else, with the piece of real estate being the tough-to-define "quality of life."

Now, the time-share metaphor only works in the carnivore vs. vegan realm if the quality of one's life moves in a positive direction because of eating meat. (Quality is a subjective thing; if you're one of those lucky folks whose taste buds have somehow been genetically engineered to actually enjoy foods that are good for you, you can waltz yourself out of this conversation.) And for me, personally, a thing that adds quality to my life is eating meat. I love it. It is delicious. The flavor, the texture, the smell, the sight of a gorgeously-cooked steak, all of it adds to an experience I enjoy. Having a quality steak or massive burger brings me a pleasure that's worth possibly going to a modestly-early grave for.

But the key point in that last phrase is "modestly."

Christopher Hitchens made the following statement on his deathbed as he considered his life of excesses:

I always knew there was a risk in the bohemiam lifestyle. I decided to take it because it helped my concentration, it stopped me being bored -- it stopped other people being boring. If you ask: would I do it again? I would probably say yes. I decided all of life is a wager, and I'm going to wager on this bit."

A noble sentiment, but one that loses some luster after remembering he died at the relatively young age of 62, after nearly a year and a half of painful cancer eating away at his body.

Me? I don't want to die in that shape at that age. While a life without meat would not be an enjoyable one, I also want to be able to jog around when I'm 65 instead of being hooked to dialysis machines. So only one of those glorious steaks every six months or so for me, please. And a burger a month. Moderation, as I've said before, is key.

But this is certainly a personal decision, one I can't really fault or criticize in either direction. (Even Hitchens'; his path just wasn't mine, except maybe when it comes to trying to drink as much whiskey as possible.) So then, where do you fit in?


Eat better by following KCET Food on Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr.

About the Author

Rick Paulas has written plenty of things, some of them serious, many of them not, scattered over the vast expanses of the Internet. He lives in Los Angeles and is a White Sox fan.
RSS icon

Previous

Fall Recipe: Corn Pudding

Next

Voting Yes on 37, Despite Its Many Flaws

LEAVE A COMMENT Leave Comment  

user-pic

Replace every instance of "eating meat" with "smoking cigarettes" in this post to reveal the flimsiness of the argument. It won't be long now before plowing into a juicy steak will carry as much stigma as smoking a filterless Marlboro.

user-pic

"Seventh-Day Adventist men live 9.5 years longer than Californian guys."

What does this mean? Do all Californian guys eat meat? Is being Californian a religion?

user-pic

Thinking your life is somehow "incomplete" in the absence of a periodic momentary flavor in your mouth sounds like some sort of psychological disorder.

user-pic

I am a new vegan, but not because I love animals or abhor cruelty. I am pleased to be at the top of the food chain, and I have been most uncomfortable those moments when I was not. I am vegan in support of my husband who isn't reacting well to hormone therapy for a rapidly growing prostate cancer. I am a foodie, having studied at the Cordon Bleu and Escoffier School in Paris. But I am throwing all my energy and creativity into creating irresistible meals loaded with antioxidants. If avoiding animal products and by-products is what it takes to avoid the ravages of both cancer and cancer treatment, then put me in, coach, I don't smoke and I'm ready to play!