News and analysis about energy in California with an eye toward renewables.

Desert Solar May Pose Threat to Desert Biofuels

Jojoba fruit | Photo: Ken Bosma/Flickr/Creative Commons License

[This story has been updated. See below the jump.]

Development in the desert can cause serious dust pollution, and utility-scale solar is no exception to that rule. Any disturbance to the desert's delicate soils can loose tons of dust into the air. (If you've driven past Ford Dry Lake on I-10 on a windy day recently, you've seen an example of this, as heavy dust off the Genesis Solar Energy Project routinely slows transcontinental traffic between Blythe and Indio.)

That dust can do more than decrease visibility, and breathability for that matter. It can also seriously affect desert plant life, including some desert plants that are being farmed as a renewable energy source themselves. And according to jojoba farmer Donna Charpied, dust blowing off the Desert Sunlight construction site adjacent to her farm in the Chuckwalla Valley has seriously damaged this year's crop of potential fuel oil.

Story Continues Below
Support KCET

Charpied, who KCET viewers may remember from an popular episode of California's Gold with Huell Howser, has been farming jojoba in the Chuckwalla Valley with her husband Larry for more than 30 years. Jojoba is an evergreen shrub native to the North American Deserts, including California's Mojave and Colorado deserts, whose seed is more than half oil. This oil is generally used in cosmetics and personal care products. Given its very long carbon chains it's long been touted as a potential biofuel crop. That's the use the Charpieds -- who call themselves "Jojoba Witnesses" -- have spent three decades promoting.

First Solar started building the 4,100-acre Desert Sunlight solar facility next door to the Charpieds' farm in September 2011, and Donna Charpied says the resulting dust has done serious damage to their crop. First Solar cleared about 1,000 acres of desert almost immediately on commencement of construction, she told ReWire, and winter dust storms off the site covered their jojoba while it was flowering, with disastrous results. According to Charpied;

When the female blooms, it sends out three little "hairs" or styles that produce a sticky substance to help catch pollen. The jojoba cannot distinguish between a particle of pollen or dust, and once it "thinks" it is pollinated it stops producing that sticky substance and goes into seed setting mode. We lost 50% of our crop this year due to false pollination, which would have been a bumper crop.
Dust above the Desert Sunlight project obscures the view of Joshua Tree National Park's Coxcomb Mountains | Photo courtesy Donna and Larry Charpied

Dust, also called "particulate matter," is a serious health hazard regulated by the EPA and state air quality management districts. Aside from car crashes during dust storms, it can cause asthma and other respiratory ailments. Airborne soil is a known vector for valley fever, and apparently it's bad for a jojoba-fueled future as well.

Charpied finds it ironic that her crop losses due to fugitive dust from the construction site can be seen as a result of development of a utility-scale solar project built with nearly $1.9 billion in Federal loan guarantees. "We grow a true 'green energy' crop that lives 200 years," she says. "It converts CO2, and does not compete for water during the summer months. And we never received a dime in government money to produce it."

Update: Donna Charpied advises us that FirstSolar has responded constructively to the farmers' concerns. See comments below.

ReWire is dedicated to covering renewable energy in California. Keep in touch by liking us on Facebook, and help shape our editorial direction by taking this quick survey here.


Ventura Firm Brings Color To Photovoltaic Panels


Brown Dedicates Controversial San Diego Transmission Line

About the Author

Chris Clarke is a natural history writer and environmental journalist currently at work on a book about the Joshua tree. He lives in Joshua Tree.
RSS icon

Add Your Response


Chris, while I agree particulate pollution has many adverse impacts, including those to human health, I can't help but wonder about the burning of jojoba oil as a fuel and the greenhouse gases it will produce...are biofuels really green? Give me true renewable energy over fictionalized biofuels!


Jojoba has tested as a fuel, with ZERO emissions. It is identical to Sperm Whale oil thus all the applications, high speed machinery, pharmecueticals, and cosmetics are among the uses for the product. It is truly a green energy biofuel as it is not food, but an industrial crop.

I must make a clarification to Chris' article. The article includes an image of semi trucks and a jojoba farm engulfed in dust. The dust occurred during the pollination window for jojoba. Of course at the time, we did not know how much our farm would be impacted.

We notified First Solar about the dust occurrence. And, in all fairness to First Solar, they have taken corrective actions to minimize dust from their facility. Chris Clarke did an excellent job on his article, but his readers would believe that the dust problem still exists. I should have conveyed that message to Chris.

Donna Charpied