News and analysis about energy in California with an eye toward renewables.

Court To Consider Injunction In Kern County Wind Case

California condor soars over the Los Padres National Forest. The birds are making a comeback in the wind-turbine-heavy Tehachapi Mountains | Photo: USFWS Pacific Southwest Region/Flickr/Creative Commons License

Plaintiffs who filed suit against Kern County over a proposed wind installation's possible threat to California condors will argue for a preliminary injunction against the project on August 1. The groups, Defenders of Wildlife, Center for Biological Diversity, and the Sierra Club, sued in October to reopen environmental review of NextEra's 100-turbine North Sky River wind project, and the smaller adjacent Jawbone project, in the mountains north of Mojave.

Story Continues Below
Support KCET


Explained: Understanding Wind Power
The groups maintain that the combined project as planned poses a serious risk to California condors, now struggling to rebuild their numbers after nearly going extinct in the 1980s. The project may also pose a threat to beleaguered golden eagles, southwestern willow flycatchers, and bats.

"There's plenty of room in the state for both wind projects and the California condor to thrive," Center for Biological Diversity biologist Ileene Anderson said when the suit was filed in October. "But if condors and wind turbines are going to coexist, those turbines need to be sited carefully and measures have to be taken to minimize the risk that condors will be killed. Unfortunately, this project fails to do that."

The North Sky River and Jawbone projects would be directly north of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power's Pine Tree Wind project, which has drawn fire for the deaths of at least six federally protected golden eagles, and thousands of other birds per year. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) calculates that Pine Tree Wind has killed 1,595 birds a year, which at 11.8 fatalities per megawatt of capacity is among the highest rates of wind turbine bird kill in the nation. FWS speculates that without bird protection measures being adopted at the nearby North Sky River and Jawbone projects, their fatality rates may well be similar.

The plaintiffs have claimed they have tried to work with wind developer NextEra to implement project features to minimize the threat to wildlife, but have been rebuffed. The groups, backed up by letters of concern from FWS and the California Department of Fish and Game, asked Kern County to insist on greater environmental protection measures, but Kern's Board of Supervisors approved the project without amendments in September 2011.

There are 200 California condors in the wild, out of a total population of 400 in the captive breeding recovery program that has staved off the birds' extinction. The birds are expanding their current range from a stronghold in Tejon Ranch toward the eastern Tehachapi range, an epicenter of California wind development. The birds' wingspans can reach nearly ten feet and they are relatively slow-maneuvering, making them especially vulnerable to large wind turbine blades. FWS will not issue take permits for the species, meaning that any wind turbine injuring a condor may face criminal charges. According to Forbes Magazine's Todd Woody, FWS warned Kern County and wind developers in 2009 that most of the projects on the drawing board for the area threatened the condor. Wind development in the area has proceeded nonetheless.

The injunction hearing will take place August 1 at the Kern County Superior Court in Bakersfield.

ReWire is dedicated to covering renewable energy in California. Keep in touch by liking us on Facebook, and help shape our editorial direction by taking this quick survey here.


Study: California is a World Geothermal Leader


Alcatraz Prison Goes Solar

About the Author

Chris Clarke is a natural history writer and environmental journalist currently at work on a book about the Joshua tree. He lives in Joshua Tree.
RSS icon

Add Your Response


There is NO WAY for California condors to exist with thousands of open bladed 500 foot tall wind turbine, period. The design of turbines are ill conceived. I believe the designers were high on something when they determined that open blades in the most sacred, sensitive mountains in the entire country are safe for birds. They are now dying by the thousands. The birds are national treasures, not trash. When they're gone, they're gone forever.
A question for all to ponder. Would a single one of the readers sky dive, glider ride or better send your children in a blimp or anythings else over the Tehachapi Pass turbines and feel it would be safe. If it wouldn't be safe for your babies, neither is it safe for Bald eagle or California condors. Those turbines need to be shut down. No compromise.

How about putting wind turbines and transmission lines in all the bird aviaries in all the zoos. Same logic. What the guests would witness are blood, wings, beaks, feet and parts and pieces on the ground like what is happening at the supposed clean energy wind farms. I don't know how else to convince my fellow country men and women to join in killing our national and natural treasures for the people to come after us.


What's up? I've submitted 2 comments, one yesterday, one today. Yet, comments indicate (0).