News and analysis about energy in California with an eye toward renewables.

Ocotillo Wind Project Shut Down After Blade Throw

Wind turbine blade and the turbine from which it was thrown | Photo: Jim Pelley

The 315-megawatt Ocotillo Express Wind project in Imperial County is shut down today after a 10-ton blade came loose from one of the project's 112 wind turbines, landing about 100 yards away on a public road. The accident took place one day after San Diego County loosened restrictions on siting large wind turbines near residential areas.

Story Continues Below
Support KCET

"It looks as though the blade came off while the tip was pointed at the ground, and then tumbled," Ocotillo resident Parke Ewing told ReWire. "I'd say the end of the blade that had been connected to the rotor landed about a football field's length away from the turbine it came off of."

According to a press release put out Thursday by local opponents of the wind project, the blade came to rest on a publicly accessible jeep trail passing through land managed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM).

"My grandchildren are out there all the time," said Ewing. "We're all just incredibly lucky that no one was killed."

Closeup of the thrown blade | Photo: Jim Pelley

Pattern Energy spokesperson Matt Dallas told ReWire that inspectors from turbine manufacturer Siemens were on site Thursday morning gathering information on the incident. We'll share that information with you as we receive it.

A press release from the local Protect Our Communities Foundation pointed out an irony in the accident's timing. "This wholly avoidable public health and safety hazard occurred just one day after San Diego County Board of Supervisors approved the revised Wind Energy Ordinance & Boulevard Community Plan to remove community protections to allow 500 foot tall industrial wind turbines on private land in previously protected areas near homes, recreation areas, and sensitive wildlife -- just like the BLM did for Pattern Energy's Ocotillo Wind," said the release.

Documented instances of blade throw with comparable wind turbines show that blades can actually travel about twice as far as Parke estimated for Thursday's incident. That's a sobering thought for travelers on Interstate 8 past Ocotillo, with turbines well within that throw distance of the freeway, as well as on Interstate 10 through North Palm Springs where similarly closely placed turbines line the roadway.

We'll update this story as it develops.


6 Ways to Look at Renewable Energy Breakthroughs That Are Too Good To Be True


Proposed Federal Fracking Rules Favor Industry

About the Author

Chris Clarke is a natural history writer and environmental journalist currently at work on a book about the Joshua tree. He lives in Joshua Tree.
RSS icon

Add Your Response


Birds hit by the turbine blades travel much further. That is why the wind industry and FWS have mortality studies that only look in a small areas around these turbines. The Smola wind farm in Norway has these same Siemens 2.3 MW turbines.

For the fools that do not believe hundreds of bald eagles are going to be chopped up each year by wind turbines, a story about dead eagles from Norway was released last week. The story includes very graphic images. Workers over the last 7 years have found 49 dead white-tailed sea eagles around the turbines at just one wind farm with 68 turbines. If they found 49 bodies then as least twice that many wandered off to die, dropped in the water or were eaten by scavengers. The white-tailed sea eagles are the European equivalent to the bald eagle.
In America if mortality searches are being conducted, any dead eagle found outside 50 meters would NOT count as a mortality and calculated in the industry's deaths/per MW/per year.


RIP poor plant workers. Y'all complain about these wind turbines, haven't provided a good alternative.