6HWbNHN-show-poster2x3-c7tgE2Y.png

Artbound

Start watching
MJ250sC-show-poster2x3-Bflky7i.png

Tending Nature

Start watching
Southland Sessions

Southland Sessions

Start watching
HvlSxHY-show-poster2x3-4ik43uV.png

Earth Focus

Start watching
5LQmQJY-show-poster2x3-MRWBpAK.jpg

Reporter Roundup

Start watching
City Rising

City Rising

Start watching
Lost LA

Lost LA

Start watching
Member
Your donation supports our high-quality, inspiring and commercial-free programming.
Support Icon
Learn about the many ways to support KCET.
Support Icon
Contact our Leadership, Advancement, Membership and Special Events teams.

Does Organic Labeling Have a Placebo Effect?

Support Provided By
organiclabel1-600
Organic syrup label | Photo: fishermansdaughter, with some heavy editing/Flickr/Creative Commons License

I've rallied on and on and on in this space about the need for accurate labels on foods -- and, surely, will continue doing so -- because it only makes sense. For consumers to be able to accurately choose what kinds of foods to purchase, they need to be accurately informed as to what exactly they're purchasing. Anything less, and it's simply throwing darts blindfolded at a giant wall. (And in this case, if you aim poorly, the darts could end up doing a 180-degree pivot at the wall and aiming their sharp points back at your body.) But throughout my rantings, I've neglected to mention the other half of the labeling relationship: The consumer.

While the producer's job is to be forthcoming about what they're producing, it's the consumer's job to actually read those labels and understand what they mean. This is what was going through my mind while reading about a compelling new study The Atlantic put together to determine how the inherent feeling about a product is informed by its label, specifically the near-ubiquitous "organic" label. I'll allow them to explain their own methodology:

In the middle of a shopping mall food court, Cornell researchers recruited 115 passersby to participate in a taste test. The participants sampled what were labeled as the organic and non-organic versions of cookies, potato chips, and yogurt. In reality, the two types of each food were identical (and, incidentally, organic). They then rated the foods on taste (Was it appetizing? Flavorful? Did it taste artificial?) and perceived nutritional content, were asked to estimate how many calories each contained, and indicated how much they'd be willing to pay for snack-sized portions of each.

That bolding is from me, seeing as it's the most important part of the whole thing.

As you'd imagine, most of the respondents enjoyed the food labeled "organic" a whole lot better than the "non-organic" version. At least, they felt it was "more nutritious" and "lower in fat and calories." (Kind of strangly, the respondents preferred the taste of the "non-organic" cookies, at least until you take into consideration that when people want their junk food, they want their junk food.) But the most important aspect of the study, the part that, no doubt, plenty of food manufacturers have already discovered using their own methodologies and test groups, is the final question asked of the respondents.

After tasting the "organic" and "non-organic" foods and talking about their various feelings, they were asked how much more they'd pay for the organic variety:

They were willing to pay up around 16 to 23 percent more.

If only we were so lucky.

As this piece in the New York Times from last June points out, in many cases companies actually charge quite a bit more than that. In the piece, the difference between Kraft Organic Mac and Cheese and the same brand's non-organic version is explored. On Amazon.com, the latter non-organic kind goes for $19.64 for a dozen 7.25-ounce boxes while the organic variety goes for $25.32 for a dozen 6-ounce boxes. Crunching the numbers, that's 23 cents an ounce for non-organic and 35 cents an ounce for organic. Crunching even further, that's about a 52% increase if you want to purchase the organic version. It makes sense, then, how the organic food industry could rake in upwards of $30 billion a year.

Which isn't to say organic foods aren't worth more, or that the value of organic should somehow be diminished. It's just that consumers need to be aware that food producers are themselves aware consumers want that organic goodness. And, more importantly, that they're willing to pay a premium for such items, thusly leaving themselves open to be exploited for simply the addition of seven simple letters on a box. Consumers have to be aware this is happening. As the study concludes, there's hope if they do:

[T]he organic labels had less of an effect on those who reported reading nutrition labels frequently and those who often bought organic, and were therefore more familiar with the foods and their marketing tactics.

In other words, the way to keep yourself from being taken advantage of by companies simply getting on the latest buzzword bandwagon is to understand what, specifically, organic means on a product-by-product basis. Maybe you don't need to buy organic everything. Or maybe you need to dig deeper on certain products to see just what, exactly, the word "organic" means. Doing anything else is simply not keeping up your end of the labeling bargain.

Eat better by following KCET Food on Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr.

Support Provided By
Read More
Aaron Choi, owner of Girl and Dug Farm, tends to a crop in a large field.

Pink Blueberries and Black Nebulas: Girl & Dug Farm's Specialty Greens Inspire Adventurous Cooking at Home

Through its commitment to biodiverse farming practices and consumer education, Girl & Dug Farm offers a hopeful example for a healthy, flavorful and culturally diverse food system.
Paul Grimm stands on the side of his painting of Harry Bennett and his horse Sonny.

In the Desert, Henry Ford's Strongman Finds His Artist's Heart

From stopping union uprisings for Henry Ford to a desert landscape painter, Harry Bennett wasn’t just a militaristic figure in corporate America but also, strangely, a skilled artist.
The view at the Slot Canyon Overlook.

Six Easy, Lesser-Known Excursions at Anza-Borrego

There's more to the Anza-Borrego Desert State Park than the wildflower blooms. Avoid the crowds and explore six of Anza-Borrego's lesser-known gems.