Skip to main content

Good News, Bad News for SoCal Edison on Nuclear Plant

Support Provided By
san-onofe-9-24-13-thumb-600x399-60415
San Onofre | Photo: exquisitur/Flickr/Creative Commons License

Southern California Edison (SCE) execs are likely breathing a sigh of relief this week as the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has opted to issue safety citations rather than fines over flawed steam generators in the utility's now-shuttered San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station.

The NRC is issuing a "Notice of Nonconformance" to Japanese vendor Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (MHI) for computer modeling design problems in the replacement steam generators it sold to SCE. The utility is also being cited for failing to perform sufficient quality control oversight as MHI designed the steam generators. But no fines are being levied on either firm, a decision that has some environmental activists shaking their heads.

Leaks in the steam generators' tubes forced a shutdown of the San Diego County nuke's Unit 3 in January, 2012, during a period in which Unit 2 was already shut down for maintenance. The utility decided to keep the power plant closed permanently this summer.

In a press statement released Monday, SCE's Chief Nuclear Officer Pete Dietrich said that it's not unusual for the NRC to cite a plant operator for failure to oversee suppliers' equipment.

"SCE is responsible for the safe operation of San Onofre and will continue to make safety our top priority as the plant is decommissioned," Dietrich said. "MHI is accountable for its failure to provide properly functioning steam generators."

Anti-nuclear actiivists, who've long criticised the plant and SCE, weren't so sanguine at the news that no fines are being levied. "It's proof that the NRC is a lap dog and not a watchdog," Friends of the Earth's Damon Moglen told the Los Angeles Times.

SCE is casting the NRC's decision as at least partial vindication in its dispute with MHI over the steam generators. In its press statement, the utility said the decision underscored its contention that MHI bears the responsibility for the faulty equipment:

[T]he NRC reports indicate that MHI's use of its computer codes in the design of the steam generators inaccurately predicted thermal hydraulic conditions in the steam generators, leading to tube vibration and wear, and a steam generator tube leak. The NRC also found that MHI embedded the same computer modeling error in the design of steam generators at four other nuclear plants, although none developed the fluid elastic instability that caused San Onofre to shut down.

Though the utility seems to have gotten support from the NRC in the San Onofre issue it can't say the same this week about the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), which has temporarily blocked attempts by SCE and San Onofre co-owner san Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) to charge ratepayers for the costs of power the utilities have had to buy to make up for San Onofre being shut down.

The proposed decision, which now must be approved by the CPUC's commissioners, will keep the utilities from passing on "procurement costs" for replacement power until a final decision is made on how much ratepayers will pay of about $3 billion in costs stemming from San Onofre's outage and decommissioning.

Those procurement costs so far total about $321 million for SCE and $69.4 million for SDG&E.

"I want to assure customers that they will not pay twice for the costs associated with the outage of San Onofre while the CPUC investigation comes to its conclusion," said CPUC Commissioner Mike Florio.

Support Provided By
Read More
Gray industrial towers and stacks rise up from behind the pitched roofs of warehouse buildings against a gray-blue sky, with a row of yellow-gold barrels with black lids lined up in the foreground to the right of a portable toilet.

California Isn't on Track To Meet Its Climate Change Mandates. It's Not Even Close.

According to the annual California Green Innovation Index released by Next 10 last week, California is off track from meeting its climate goals for the year 2030, as well as reaching carbon neutrality by 2045.
A row of cows stands in individual cages along a line of light-colored enclosures, placed along a dirt path under a blue sky dotted with white puffy clouds.

A Battle Is Underway Over California’s Lucrative Dairy Biogas Market

California is considering changes to a program that has incentivized dairy biogas, to transform methane emissions into a source of natural gas. Neighbors are pushing for an end to the subsidies because of its impact on air quality and possible water pollution.
A Black woman with long, black brains wears a black Chicago Bulls windbreaker jacket with red and white stripes as she stands at the top of a short staircase in a housing complex and rests her left hand on the metal railing. She smiles slightly while looking directly at the camera.

Los Angeles County Is Testing AI's Ability To Prevent Homelessness

In order to prevent people from becoming homeless before it happens, Los Angeles County officials are using artificial intelligence (AI) technology to predict who in the county is most likely to lose their housing. They would then step in to help those people with their rent, utility bills, car payments and more so they don't become unhoused.