Quechan Tribe Says 'Not So Fast' on Large Solar Power Plant

Artist''s rendering, Palen Solar Electric Generating System | Photo: BrightSource Energy

Comment on a proposed large solar energy installation is coming in after the California Energy Commission (CEC) published its initial assessment, and one of the most striking pieces of feedback comes from a nearby tribe. Formal comment on the CEC's Preliminary Staff Assessment for the Palen Solar Electric Generating System by the Historic Preservation Office of the Quechan Indian Tribe in Yuma was posted to the CEC's website Wednesday, and that comment minces no words about the project, or about the regulatory process that they feel is pushing the project along despite opposition.

The Quechan, currently based on and near the Fort Yuma Indian Reservation straddling the state line near Yuma, Arizona, traditionally traveled the area in Riverside County that would be occupied by the Palen project. Along with other local tribes, they hold many places in the area as important to their culture and religion.

The Palen project is proposed by Palen Solar Holdings, a joint venture of BrightSource Energy and Abengoa. The facility would generate up to 500 megawatts of power by using tens of thousands of mirrored heliostats on 5,200 acres of public lands to focus solar energy onto boilers atop two 750-foot power towers, each less than two miles from Interstate 10 between Blythe and Desert Center in Riverside County.

Story continues below

The project was approved by the CEC in 2010 under different ownership and with a radically different design, and the current round of agency evaluation -- technically known as a petition to amend the CEC's original certification of the project -- is intended to determine what changes in the plant's operating agreement with the state might be required due to its redesign as a power tower facility.

Palen Solar Holdings has made it known that the partnership is counting on a speedy approval of the amended project in order to meet lenders' deadlines. During a June 3 conference of involved parties, Palen's attorney Scott Galati objected to CEC staff requests for additional surveys of cultural resources on the project site, saying that such studies threatened to delay the project to the point where the companies might not be able to close financing by the end of 2013, threatening the possibility of firing up the plant on schedule.

In its comments this week, the Quechan Historic Preservation Office objected to that rush in no uncertain terms, saying that the applicant's need for speed threatened to steamroll its far less well funded opponents.

As if to underscore the disparity in resources available to the participants, a series of storms took out power to the Fort Yuma Reservation for much of the week, a fact that the tribe's comments played up:

The Tribe is asking for more time to survey local cultural sites and anthropologists' reports, for the CEC to prepare Ethnographic Studies on the setting and viewshed as part of the project's assessment rather than as later mitigation, and for greater Tribal input in the project's compliance, monitoring, and mitigation plans.

The Tribe is also suggesting the project be redesigned as a photovoltaic generating station on the grounds that such a configuration is less visually obtrusive. As BrightSource has staked its future on its power tower technology, Palen Solar Holdings is unlikely to seize on that last suggestion.

The CEC has scheduled a formal evidentiary hearing on the project on September 16.

For ongoing environmental coverage in March 2017 and afterward, please visit our show Earth Focus, or browse Redefine for historic material.
KCET's award-winning environment news project Redefine ran from July 2012 through February 2017.

We are dedicated to providing you with articles like this one. Show your support with a tax-deductible contribution to KCET. After all, public media is meant for the public. It belongs to all of us.

Keep Reading