Supreme Court Hands Victory for Environmentalists in L.A. Urban Runoff Case | KCET
Supreme Court Hands Victory for Environmentalists in L.A. Urban Runoff Case
The U.S. Supreme Court yesterday declined Los Angeles County and the County Flood Control District's request to review a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that found Los Angeles County liable for untreated stormwater pollution. The decision effectively allows the original ruling to remain in place, holding the Los Angeles County liable for water pollution at the Los Angeles and San Gabriel Rivers.
"After six years of litigation, it is finally official: Los Angeles County must take responsibility for its polluted stormwater runoff in the Los Angeles and San Gabriel Rivers," said Steve Fleischli, senior attorney and water program director for the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), in a statement. "This water quality victory puts an end to Los Angeles County's persistent attempts to avoid liability for its massive water pollution problem, which threatens the health of millions of Southern California residents and visitors who enjoy beloved local rivers and beaches."
More on water pollution and clean water
Urban runoff is one the major causes of water pollution in Southern California. As water flows over concrete, roofs and streets, it picks up dirt, oil, pesticides, and litter, draining it toward local waterways and eventually out to the ocean.
In 2008, the NRDC and the Los Angeles Waterkeeper filed a lawsuit for that untreated runoff. It held the Los Angeles County and the County Flood Control District responsible for documented violations of the County's Clean Water Act permit in the Los Angeles and San Gabriel Rivers since 2003.
"There is no finding that the county or district is responsible," clarified Howard Gest, outside counsel for the county. Gest explained that the monitoring stations that showed exceedances that were the basis for the original lawsuit included waste produced from industrial facilities and wastewater plants upstream. It is still to be decided in the district court if the county is liable for an amount of pollution.
"The county doesn't have to clean up anyone else's pollution. Only their own," wrote Fleischli in response. "But they can't walk away from a problem they undoubtedly contribute to (they are by far the largest operator of the stormdrain system) by saying that other people are polluting too."
Los Angeles once argued that it couldn't be held responsible for pollution that could have originated from a thousand other points up the Los Angeles watershed, which was an argument that held no water in trial. "The trial court can make sure apportionment is fair, and with liability now established, this decision helps ensure that the County will be responsible for cleaning up its share of the problem."
In the meantime, the Los Angeles County Department of Public Works are already considering some measures that may also help alleviate the excesses that are at issue, such as enforcing low-impact development regulations, which encourage large projects to retain water on-site to be cleaned.
Connect with KCET
Children whose educations have been disrupted by the pandemic may suffer life-long consequences, including shorter life spans, according to a study released today by the UCLA Fielding School of Public Health.
Many artists find work has dried up due to COVID-19, but it doesn’t mean you have to stop working entirely. Several artists and people who work with artists share their best tips on things to do when work is slow.
Los Angeles County health officials announced Nov. 23 a record-high daily number of cases that is expected to trigger a more sweeping stay-at-home order.
Can Online Avatars Define Us? Animator Jenna Caravello Dives Into This, the Art of Online Storytelling and Pepe the Frog
Meet Jenna Caravello, the mind-bendingly creative brain who uses video games, interactive installations and animated short films as ways to help us make sense of memory, loss and meaning.
- 1 of 397
- next ›
Earth Focus tells the story of Harry Reid, a politician who grew up in an Old West mining town, saw the possibility of a New West emerging in Nevada, and rode that change to power.
In-depth profiles of four young environmentalists: Alexandria Villaseñor in California, Carl Smith in Alaska, Ayakha Melithafa in South Africa and Litokne Kabua in the Marshall Islands.
South Africa faces a stark reality as the continent’s largest greenhouse gas emitter.
This episode follows chief environmental prosecutor Karina Garay as she works with the police, army and navy in destroying illegal mines and arresting miners in protected areas
The global demand for oil and gas has long-lasting impacts on the communities that supply it.
- 1 of 10
- next ›